Best Indoor and Outdoor Turkey Fryers 2019 – Buyer’s Guide and Reviews

Roasting a turkey is a time-consuming process and seems like a project. What will we not give to be able to enjoy Thanksgiving without spending all our time getting the turkey ready? The right answer to this is to try frying it the next time.

And this is where you ask if the best turkey fryer is good enough to replace your oven. Our answer is yes, find the best turkey fryer for your needs. They are both convenient and easy to use, and the results good too. The key to getting the best-fried turkey lies in choosing the right fryer, your recipe, knowing the right temperature and time settings, and also the right choice of oil to fry the turkey.

Types of turkey fryers

  1. a) Outdoor Turkey Fryers – These are versatile in terms of taking them along when you go camping, tailgating, or anywhere else from your backyard to a friend’s garden. These run on propane, which again is easily portable. Another key advantage of an outdoor fryer is how quickly the oil heats up.

A few key points to keep in mind are following the manufacturer’s instructions and all safety measures while using an outdoor turkey fryer. A few outdoor turkey fryers these days are oil-less. These use radiant heat and are capable of giving you a crispy on the outside and juicy inside the result. So you need to check which kind of outdoor fryer you want to get. We have reviewed both types here to make it easier for you to choose from.

  1. b) Indoor Electric Turkey Fryers – Safety and convenience on these fryers is unmatched. If you regularly battle bad weather and other challenges to outdoor cooking, these are the best turkey fryers for you. Masterbuilt has a range of models that are both durable and easy to use.

One significant difference in terms of performance of an outdoor and indoor fire is the high temperature you can get on an outdoor one. Most indoor fryers go up to the highest temperature of 375 degrees. Safety features like a thermostat, timer, and closed lid cooking make indoor turkey fryers the right choice.

Outdoor – Best Turkey Fryer

1. Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Oil-Less Turkey Fryer
2. Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer
3. Bayou Classic 1118 32-Quart Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer
4. Bayou Classic 3025 30-Quart Aluminum Turkey Fryer Pot with Accessories
5. Masterbuilt 20100809 Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster
6. Turkey Deep Fryer Oversized 44 Quart Stainless Steel “Big Bird” Kit
7. Chard TFP30A Aluminum Turkey Fryer Pack

Indoor – Best Turkey Fryer

1. Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer
2. Masterbuilt 20010109 Butterball Professional Series Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer
3. Butterball MB23010118 Electric Fryer, Large
4. Butterball XXL Digital 22 lb. Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Steel, and Black
5. Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer (Largest Capacity, Newest Model)

Outdoor Turkey Fryer Reviews

1. Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

Check Price on Amazon Now!

This one is an oil-less turkey fryer that is built for outdoor use. The Char-boil big easy has its TRU-Infrared technology and hence does not require oil for frying. If you are into air-frying or oil-less frying, this product is a winner. You can cook a 16 lb turkey easily without worrying about hot and cold spots, oil splatters, and other turkey fryer related accidents.

The fryer runs on propane and comes with a cooking basket, a turkey lifter, a thermometer, and two knobs with temperature control. There is a drip tray that catches all the grease and drippings. You can try using it for cooking the gravy. The fryer can be used for other kinds of meats too.

2. Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer

Check Price on Amazon Now!

This one is also an oil-less turkey fryer from Char-boil. It runs on propane and cannot be used indoors. You can cook 16 lbs of turkey and other meats like chickens and more. Features for this Big Easy model are similar to the one we have reviewed above. It also runs on TRU-Infrared technology and gives great results.

Some people love it more because of the quick cooking time. As the heat is generated through infra-red technology, there is no danger of oil-splattering or fires. The fryer comes with a front access drip tray, a cooking basket, and a turkey lifter.

3. Bayou Classic 1118 32-Quart Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer

Check Price on Amazon Now!

Bayou Classic 1118 32 is the best stainless steel turkey fryer to sell. This is a large outdoor turkey fryer. You can cook an 18-20 lbs turkey easily with this. It will take you 3 gallons of oil and just over 40 minutes. The fryer, as well as all components, are made up of stainless steel. It comes with a pot, lid, skewer, stand, meat injector, stainless steel thermometer, the hook, and the hook basket.

Being stainless steel, the fryer is easy to clean compared to the aluminum ones. One thing you will need to consider is that the fryer is 32 quart and will not fit on most propane burners. You might need Bayou’s cooker, which is made specifically for these fryers. A lot of users have also complained of poor durability. The fryer develops holes in and starts to leak.

4. Bayou Classic 3025 30-Quart Aluminum Turkey Fryer Pot with Accessories

Check Price on Amazon Now!

The Bayou Classic turkey fryer is made of high-grade aluminum. A 30-quart fryer lets you cook an 18 lbs. Turkey in less than an hour. The fryer comes with a 12-inch stainless steel thermometer, a perforated poultry rack, hook, and a cooker.

You need about 3 gallons of oil, the design is made to be spill-proof, but we recommend to follow the manufacturer’s instructions and ensure that the fryer is not running when you are putting the turkey in and when you are taking it out. Aluminum does not work as well as steel, and this model, too, has issues with the base developing holes.

5. Masterbuilt 20100809 Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster

Check Price on Amazon Now!

The Butterball from Masterbuilt is an electric oil-less air. It has a double-wall built, and the cooking happens through radiant heat. It comes with a drip box and a wood chip box. You can cook an 18 lbs turkey in the fryer easily. Its tempered lid allows you to check on the food getting cooked.

We experienced uneven heating, and the bird also took a long time to cook. It has heat control dials but does not have temperature ranges mentioned. The good idea is to go with your recipe and check the temperature with a meat thermometer. This can be a good option if you are looking to buy an electric turkey fryer.

6. Turkey Deep Fryer Oversized 44 Quart Stainless Steel “Big Bird” Kit

Check Price on Amazon Now!

This is by far the largest turkey fryer in the market. It can easily cook a 25 lbs pound bird. Made of aluminum and stainless steel finish on the outside. This large 44-quart turkey fryer comes from Bayou. It runs on propane and is easily portable. Another differentiating feature it has is that it stands about 1 foot above the ground, making it ergonomic and easier to use for long cooking sessions.

Some of the accessories you get with this unit include perforated poultry rack made of aluminum, thermometer, hook, stainless steel injector, and an insulated glove. We loved the size, but you will need to check if you want this big a fryer or not.

7. Chard TFP30A Aluminum Turkey Fryer Pack

Check Price on Amazon Now!

This is an aluminum turkey fryer comes with a 17-inch stand, a temperature regulator, a safety timer, poultry rack, a 12-inch thermometer, and a safety hanger. The pot is 30 quarts, and you can cook 13 to 16 lbs. turkey in it.

The safety timer is a much-hated feature with most users. The burner will shut off every 15 minutes, and you have to restart it every time. We, too, feel this can be bothersome and that there could have been a more thought out safety feature than this one. Another gripe we have is with the build quality. The pot itself seems to thin, and the stand is even flimsier.

Indoor Turkey Fryer Reviews

1. Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Check Price on Amazon Now!

Master’s Butterball indoor turkey fryer is a much-loved product. It is a sturdy and well-built fryer and is a good choice if you can’t go for an outdoor fryer. It can cook a 20 lbs turkey, making a great addition to your Thanksgiving cooking. It has adjustable temperature control, a drip clip, and an in-built filter. The timer ensures you don’t have to watch over your turkey constantly.

We found the extension cord a little too short and the fact that the temperature of the oil drops considerably on adding the bird. The drop in temperature means you have to cook the bird for longer. The lid ensures there is no splatter and increases safety and convenience.

2. Masterbuilt 20010109 Butterball Professional Series Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Check Price on Amazon Now!

Another great product from Masterbuilt this one is a great addition to your kitchen with its stainless steel finish and sturdy built. The fryer can easily cook a 14 lbs turkey and gets up to 275-300 degrees max. The cooking basket comes with a drip clip, a drain valve, and an inbuilt oil filter. The cord is too short on this one also.

The fryer is very easy to clean, and with a see-through lid, it avoids splatters. The Butterball 20010109 has enough features to be your choice of a turkey fryer. The cord and the fact that we do not get as high a temperature as we would love to are the only gripes we have with this one.

3. Butterball MB23010118 Electric Fryer, Large

Check Price on Amazon Now!

This fryer in the Butterball indoor electric fryer series by Masterbuilt is quite large. You will discover all the great features that Masterbuilt has given to its indoor fryers. Here we are talking about a drip clip in the cooking basket, a see-through lid, temperature control and timer, and great looks.

The fryer can easily cook a 14 lb turkey and can give good results with the least bit of fuss. The cleaning is easy and convenient with dishwasher safe components and the drain valve. You can put a little over 2 gallons of oil in this high capacity fryer and would need to pre-heat for up to 30 minutes.

4. Butterball XXL Digital 22 lb. Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Steel and Black

Check Price on Amazon Now!

The biggest Butterball from Masterbuilt, this indoor fryer, is a favorite for us. It can easily cook a 20 lb. turkey, and if that too indoors, that is pretty amazing. The results were great, and we were able to cook a 15 lbs turkey in about 60 minutes.

Just keep in mind that the oil will take a little longer to heat if you are cooking an enormous bird. Also, take into account that the temperature of the oil will drop on putting the bird in. Just account for this time and cook accordingly. The fryer has all the accessories and features of the Butterball series.

5. Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer (Largest Capacity, Newest Model)

Check Price on Amazon Now!

Here we have one of the latest models of Masterbuilt’s XXL size Butterball indoor fryer. While the older model comes in steel and black, this one is a sleek all-black model. The biggest advantage of all models in the Butterball series is the features that make it safe and convenient. Right from the drain valve, the timer, lid, and temperature controls.

The good looking fryer has digital temperature controls and a thermostat. It is a safety feature that lets you cook your recipes with repeated use. One thing we missed on this near-perfect fryer is a vented lid.

Final thoughts for the best turkey fryer

Now that you are armed with enough info about the best turkey fryers out there, you can go ahead get the one you like best.

Whether you choose an outdoor or an indoor turkey fryer, do keep in mind the following safety tips.

  1. Always thaw and completely dry your turkey before putting it in hot oil. You can also use a paper towel to ensure there is no moisture left.
  2. Switch off the burner when putting your turkey in to avoid splatters.
  3. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions on how much oil to put in. Putting in more oil can result in spillage and fires too.
  4. For outdoor propane fryer ensure you keep it away from any combustible object, avoid using a wooden base go for asphalt and keep the propane tank as far away as possible.
  5. For indoor fryers, they should have a breakaway cord to avoid accidental tripping. The Butterball models we have reviewed above all have a breakaway cord.
  6. Check the internal temperature before bringing the bird out.

A turkey frying is straightforward and gives excellent results. While you cannot fry a stuffed turkey, go for a spice rub or try injecting your turkey If you want more flavor. Enjoy a delicious turkey this Thanksgiving!